Skip to content
Northern Voyages

Guardians Who Record Their Children Sobbing for Clicks Ought to Reflect at Their Behavior

One specific tune has been residing in my mind this seven days, and no, it doesn't come from the singer's latest album. It comes by a far more refined songwriter: a children's entertainer. The piece is titled Big Feelings and its words go: “Big feelings are OK / I’m here to stay with your big feelings.”

The Emergence of Intense Reactions On Social Media

Thanks to the trend for conscious parenting, the notion of “big feelings” has transformed into lucrative online, and generally I support that. As a parent, intense emotions are difficult to avoid: you are having them, the youngster in your household is experiencing them and, in one of the biggest changes for us as a society, so are numerous other children on your digital streams.

In fact, recordings of infants and children weeping is so commonplace on various platforms that a lot of parents don't even question it. I avoid TikTok and my Instagram algorithm is mostly focused on stew and the occult, but when a associate told me that she thought the trend concerning, not to mention unethical, I viewed some of the videos myself.

My Observations: Children at Their Most Fragile

What I found was video after video of children at their most vulnerable. Weeping, shouting, shrieking, and sometimes acting out. I have of course been observant to these instances in my own home, but seeing someone else’s child enduring it feels profoundly disturbing, especially when that child is not receiving solace by their own parent. Most unacceptable is a genre of video in which parents subject their children to medical procedures while their little one weeps and shouts right into the recording. It must be noted that most of the videos are different, and yet there is nonetheless something unsettling about them all.

In Cases Where Strong Emotions Do Not Become Upsetting

Naturally, “big feelings” do not always have to be entirely upsetting. When your child is sprawling on the pavement upset at the discovery that sweets don't last forever it can be difficult to keep a straight face. Many of us have been regaled with tales of particularly unforgettable tantrums of our own. One of mine involved screaming “GIVE ME ALL YOUR MONEY!” in the foyer of the a cultural center in downtown. Lightheartedly joking your child about a time they had a outburst, or sharing a laugh with your partner once they have fallen asleep, is acceptable. Filming a child in a moment of vulnerability and sharing it to the online world for all to see without permission is a distinct concern altogether.

Concerning Phenomena and Shaming

Additionally you have the practices that are simply concerning, such as one that included surprising babies into silence by flinging a processed food at their faces, or breaking an egg on them. This content seems geared towards shaming children. In an article for the a major publication, a writer wrote: “The eeriest part of these videos [is that] the parents are hardly connecting to their kids. Instead they are relating to a mirror image of their children that they are sharing online. And they are reveling in their power over that image.”

The Explanation of Teachability

A number of video producers who would strongly oppose this sort of content. They state that they are filming their children at their most exposed not to mock them, but because they are attempting to develop teachable moments – “observe how calmly and effectively I was able to manage this child’s meltdown using these strategies”. A few even try to prevent expected criticism. “This video is shared to inform and increase understanding – not for support or opinions”, a particular clip, shared by an profile run by a paediatrician, reportedly states. The statement that follows is some of the most self-praising nonsense I have read on the internet. “If you aren't living the life, refrain from criticizing the moment.”

A Challenge of Responsibility

What if you avoid posting the moment? I can't help but ask. Because I certainly critique these people. What I see, when I observe a video of a small child in distress, whether their parent is demonstrating reassurance or not, is a failure of responsibility – the obligation to be present for your child. And I wonder what signal it conveys, that when your child begins showing a “big feeling”, you get your phone out. What does that say to your child about their wholly natural emotions? “Sharing real moments is part of the learning”, supposedly.

Considerations on Child Development

When my partner and I begin exploring schools for our youngster, it’s difficult not to reflect on how approaches to parenting have changed since we were young. There is an increased awareness of the fact that “big feelings” are expected for little ones. These days many adults attempt to acknowledge those emotions and provide children a secure environment in which to express themselves. Yet despite what the modern parenting experts assert, I do not think you can really provide a protected setting for your child if you are recording their times of weakness and invading their privacy and dignity in the procedure. If I’m honest, I don’t think these people have a great deal to teach any of us about upbringing.

A Final Question

Certain individuals who will find that extreme, who would recoil from the fact that in particular aspects I’d prefer put a dairy product on my child's face for a laugh than take advantage of his distress as a educational instance for engagement. But to them I would respond this: if “every action is communication”, what, precisely, are these parents trying to say?

Written by

Monica Johnson

A certified wellness coach passionate about holistic health and empowering others to live balanced lives through mindful practices.

Northern Voyages

Type to search articles.